All
← Back to Squawk list
Memorial Day: The Tribulations of the DC-10.
In Ask the Pilot: Memorial Day. The Tribulations of the DC-10. (askthepilot.com) More...Sort type: [Top] [Newest]
In 2007, a Boeing 737-200 operating Nationwide flight 723 out of FACT lost its right hand engine which separated during climb-out, but unlike AA191, the crew regained control and landed safely. An outstanding feat of piloting by Captain Trevor Arnold and 1st Officer Daniel Perry, who was the pilot flying.
See https://aviation-safety.net/asndb/321836 & https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6kccBc-FBQ
See https://aviation-safety.net/asndb/321836 & https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i6kccBc-FBQ
AA 191 was at a speed greater than V2. The procedure at that time for an engine failure was to climb at V2. When the Captain reduced speed to V2 he lost control due to the slats being retracted.
After flying jets in the USAF and transitioning to the airline industry I was amazed at the FAA's insistence on flying at V2 for the engine failure if you were already above that speed - especially close to Mother Earth. You can fly around the world at 10 feet altitude is you have lots of airspeed, but without the airspeed, no matter your altitude, you are in deep trouble - especially close to Mother Earth!
191...heard they put several pilots thru a simulation of the crash... the only crew that "survived" pushed the throttles "balls to the walls" to overcome loss of lift...
I remember it well. At the time, I was based at CVG and lived in Northern Kentucky. On the evening of that crash, a Friday, my girlfriend at the time decided she wanted to go to a Conway Twitty concert with her ex-husband! When she returned, I confronted her in the bathroom and flushed her engagement ring down the toilet in front of her! In regard to the France crash, there's excellent coverage of that in the book "Destination Disaster". I've read it several times. Another incident also related to explosive decompression due to that cargo door design occurred over Lake Ontario on June 12, 1972. The flight crew had little to no control authority over the control surfaces. The PIC used differential thrust to turn around and returned to DTW. He had recently practiced that technique in the sim. That flight was American Airlines flight 96 with the NTSB report: AAR-73-2.
Ground control came on the radio and said "They've lost a heavy at O'hare." I turned around and looked south and saw a monster mushroom cloud going up - Wow...